Advaita Vedanta: Epistemology-Classical Indian Philosophy for Kerala PSC

Download PDF of This Page (Size: 231K)

Advaita Vedanta- Epistemology

Advaita Vedanta- Epistemology

Advaita Vedanta- Epistemology

Complete Video at - Advaita Vedanta : Epistemology - Classical Indian Philosophy (Philosophy)

Literature

  • The central texts of Advaita Vedanta tradition are Upanishads, Bhagavad Gita and Brahma Sutras. These three texts collectively called Prasthana-trayi. They are;

    • Upanishads or the Shruti prasthana: The Vedic scriptures have contributed towards the formation of the Vedanta or Uttar-Mimamsa. Upanishads such as Chandogya and Brihadaranyaka are often quoted in the Vedanta schools.

    • The Brahma sutras or Nyaya prasthana: It is also known as Yukti prasthana. This has contributed towards in the formation of the reason based teachings of Vedanta school. Brahma-sutra deals with a compilation of the teachings of the Upanishads.

    • The Bhagavad Gita: It is also known as Smriti prashtana. It is regarded as a smriti or remembered tradition which lead to the foundation of Vedanta.

  • Advaita Vedanta school is an orthodox school of Indian philosophy, as a result, it accepts Shruti as a reliable source of knowledge. Shruti includes the works of four vedas, namely, Rig, Sama, Yajur and Atharva veda. It also includes the Samhitas, the Brahmanas, the Aryanakas and the Upanishads.

Complete notes and preparation module at doorsteptutor.com

Pramanas

  • According to Advaita Vedanta school of Shankara, all the six means of knowledge or the sources of knowledge (pramanas) are accepted. They are;

  • Pratyaksha or perception:

    • According to him, perception is of two types; internal perception and external perception.

    • The latter arises when there is a contact of an external object with the five external senses.

    • The former arises from the perception of the inner sense organ, mind. For example, intuition, perception of universals, etc.

    • He maintains there are four conditions for perception to be possible. They are;

      • Indriyarthasannikarsha- there must be a direct experience of the object with the senses for the correct perception to take place.

      • Avyapadesya- perception to be true in nature can never depend on hearsay.

      • Avyabhicara- correct perception does not change, it is definite in nature.

      • Vyavasayatmaka- correct perception does not deal with doubts, errors, etc.

      • Anumana or Inference:

      • Anumana or inference means after-knowledge.

      • This is because anumana literally means cognition or knowledge which follows from some other knowledge. Anu means after and mana means knowledge.

      • Therefore, anumana deals with knowledge which comes first from some other means of knowledge.

      • According to Indian Logic, anumana or inference deals with both deductive and inductive arguments.

      • The five propositions of a syllogism are;

      • The hill has fire (proposition that we want to prove or pratijna)

      • Because it has smoke (reason or hetu)

      • Whatever has smoke has fire, eg. an oven (example or udharana)

      • The hill has smoke (application of the universal relation of smoke-fire to the present case or upanaya)

      • Therefore, the hill has fire (conclusion or nigamana)

    • Upamana or Comparison:

    • It deals with a relation between two things, a name and a thing denoted by that name.

    • For example, a man who has never seen a cow goes to the jungle and sees an animal with four legs, long tail and is reminded how his friend once told him that a cow is an animal which has four legs and a long tail, so, the man recognises that animal in the judge is a cow.

    • This is also known as knowledge via resemblance, examples, analogy, and denotation.

    • Valid knowledge via the means of comparison is called upamiti.

  • Arthapatti or Postulation:

    • It is the means of knowledge where the necessary supposition of an unperceived fact is made to explain a thing.

    • For example, when a fat man who does not eat during the day is taken into consideration, we suppose that because he is fat, he must eat, so he eats during the night.

    • Here, our supposition that he eats during the night helps us explain the nature of the man who is fat.

    • Arthapatti is used when a given phenomenon is such that we cannot understand it unless we suppose some fact regarding it to help ourselves understand it.

    • Hence, it is called knowledge via assumption or presumptions or supposition.

  • Anupalabdhi or Non-apprehension:

    • It deals with the immediate knowledge of something non-existent.

    • In other words, negation or absence of something is known through Non-Apprehension or Non-Perception (Anupalabdhi) pramana .

    • It is the only pramana which deals with the knowledge of something absent or not existent or not present (abhava).

    • For example, the teacher is not in the class- means, the teacher is absent or non-existent (abhava).

  • Sabda or Verbal Testimony:

    • Verbal Testimony means knowledge that arises from the words of a trustworthy person (either spoken or written).

    • They are also called aptavakya, meaning, words from an authentic authority (agama) which are error free, reliable, and not false.

    • According to Advaita Vedanta, sabda is the most important pramana.

MCQs

1. Prasthana-trayi includes

A. Gita, Upanishad and Vedas.

B. Rig Veda, Yajur Veda and Sama Veda

C. Upanishads, Bhagavad Gita and Brahma Sutras.

D. Upanishads, Gita and Rig Veda

Answer: C

2. Another name for Brahman sutra is

A. Nyaya Prasthana

B. Yukti Prasthana

C. Both A and B

D. Shruti prasthana

Answer: C

3. Indriyarthasannikarsha, Avyapadesya, Avyabhicara and Vyavasayatmaka are the four conditions of

A. Perception

B. Inference

C. Verbal Testimony

D. Postulation

Answer: A

4. The five propositions of a syllogism are;

A. Hetu, udharana, pratijna, upanaya, naigamana

B. Upanaya, hetu, udharana, pratijna, naigamana

C. Pratijna, hetu, upanaya, udharana, naigamana

D. Pratijna, hetu, udharana, upanaya, naigamana

Answer: D

5. Shruti includes ______ works

A. 4 vedas, Samhitas, the Brahmanas, the Aryanakas and the Upanishads.

B. 3 vedas, Samhitas, Aryanakas, Upanishads,

C. Only 4 vedas

D. Samhitas, the Brahmanas, the Aryanakas and the Upanishads.

Answer: A

#Advaita

#Vedanta

#Epistemology

#Knowledge

Glide to success with Doorsteptutor material for UGC - Get detailed illustrated notes covering entire syllabus: point-by-point for high retention.

Developed by: