Journal vs. Research Paper vs. Thesis: Research Aptitude YouTube Lecture Handouts

Get top class preparation for CTET/Paper-2 right from your home: get questions, notes, tests, video lectures and more- for all subjects of CTET/Paper-2.

Journal vs. Research Paper vs. Thesis: Research Aptitude

Title: Journal vs Paper vs Thesis

What is Thesis?

tithenai meaning “to place”

  • Etymology of thesis dates back to the Greek word tithenai which means “to place.” This early definition was concerned with topographical and locative origins with an intentional infinitive that indicated “putting forth” of something in a pre-defined place. From there onwards, the early Greek word mutated into ‘thesis’ which in Greek meant “to put forth something” like “a proposal” . This meaning sustained through Latin scholarship and through the Middle Ages and the Renaissance into modernity. To put forth a proposal became related to the central theme or statement of a scholarly argument.
  • Separate ‘nodes’ of knowledge or ‘axioms’ connected to form the ‘hypo-thesis’ or something that was lesser (hypo) than the ‘thesis’ but was also a projected mind-picture of the same. The ‘hypothesis’ led to the central statement of the scholarly argument. This central theme or statement of a scholarly argument is known as the ‘thesis’ . It is around the thesis that all other statements and evidence revolve to prove its validity.

What is Dissertation?

dissertātiō meaning “path”

The word ‘dissertation’ is derived from the Latin word dissertātiō which means ‘path’ . In some countries, dissertation is also referred to as ‘thesis’ . Oxford Dictionary defines dissertation as ‘a long essay on a particular subject or topic especially written for university degree or diploma’ .

What is Research Paper?

Repetition of search

  • The ‘research paper’ , on the other hand, might be defined as any piece of original and plagiarism-free research. The term, ‘research’ , is concerned with the repetition of search (re-search) . Repetitive searches in various directions to prove the central thesis question is generally known as ‘research’ .
  • The research paper will usually, if not always, consist of the central thesis question. 2 kinds of research papers, one of them being qualitative and the other quantitative.
Journal is an Article Which Consists of Some Specific Criteria
JournalPaperThesis
Article with Specific CriteriaInformative SheetIn-depth Study

Journal is an article which consists of some specific criteria. A paper is an informative sheet. Thesis includes a deep study under the guidance of some respected person.

Journal is an Article Which Consists of Some Specific Criteria
JournalPaperThesis
Specific format for writingDescription & detailed layoutLong piece of writing on a subject to earn degree
  • The meaning of the word journal means a book in which you write down your personal experiences and thoughts. Journals are informative book logs. They have a pre-defined form of content which are to be followed accordingly. Journals are used for referring purposes.
  • A thesis document should be an approved document; its range may vary according to the type of research done. Thesis writing is a proposed form of writing. It includes the detailed study material right from the origin till its final product. It also explains the current status of the product. These are mostly written in order to secure the research.
Journal is an Article Which Consists of Some Specific Criteria
JournalPaperThesis
Includes many topics which are co-relatedContent related to a topicOnly one topic is included
Research is not deepResearch manual of journals and thesisDeep research
Create awareness about current topicConvey subject to relevant userAchieve degree
Around 5,000 to 6,000 wordsLength is proportional to studyAround 20,000 to 80,000 words
Common themeSpeculative variables & constantsCentral line of inquiry is constant

While the thesis question opens up the boundaries of these variable possibilities, the central line of inquiry remains constant and unchanged. The research paper consists of both speculative variables (majority of which are nullified) and constants that are geared towards proving the central thesis question or the major constant.

Journal is an Article Which Consists of Some Specific Criteria
PaperThesis
Proving central argumentCentral question that leads to research
  • Thesis is both about possibilities, through the formation of numerous anti-theses, and about the end of all possibilities through the nullification of all these anti-theses. The research paper is about proving the central thesis statement and concerned with gathering evidence and data to prove the same, exploring other possibilities and nullifying them and providing a speculation on future alternatives for the central thesis question. To be precise, the research paper is all about explicating and proving the thesis.
  • The thesis usually is formed through extensive original thinking that puts forth a proposal or statement, but the research paper requires tenacious resilience on part of the researcher to justify the central question. The latter is a long process in which there is gathering of evidence, raising and nullification of various other possibilities and the application of theories and evidence to the central research question. All this is done towards proving the thesis. The research paper might be called an expansion and extension of the central thesis.
  • The word thesis is sometimes used in place of research paper, but this is a rhetorical error in which a part is substituted for a whole. The thesis statement is usually a part of the research paper and not vice-versa.
Place of Research Paper
PaperThesis
Has Methodology

Number of questions

No methodology

Single question

  • Thesis statement does not consist of the methodology. The research paper explicates this methodology and whether it is quantitative or qualitative.
  • The thesis statement is an end in itself.
  • The thesis statement is about a single question while the research paper raises a number of questions albeit in relation to the central theme. Some of these questions are nullified and some remain as the indicators of alternative discourses.
  • The research paper usually consists of the thesis, but it is not always so. The research paper might be on a part of the thesis question and can have stand-alone validity.

Developed by: